Back to top

Twin Cities Streetcar Strike, 1889

  • Cite
  • Share
  • Correct
  • Print
Black and white scan of "The best way to settle it." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.

"The Best Way To Settle It." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.

Wage cuts to employees of the Minneapolis and St. Paul streetcar companies in 1889 prompted a fifteen-day strike that disrupted business and escalated into violence before its resolution. In spite of public support for the strikers, the streetcar companies succeeded in breaking the strike with few concessions.

In early April 1889, streetcar magnate Thomas Lowry announced a 15 percent pay cut for all company employees to help cover the cost of new cable car lines. Reductions ranged from one to four cents per hour, depending upon the position. Workers saw the cuts as a contract violation and a clear indication of Lowry's anti-union stance.

Local newspapers speculated that the streetcar drivers would strike during the busy summer season. It is possible that Lowry precipitated the strike by implementing the wage cuts in the spring to minimize revenue loss.

On April 11, 1889, six hundred Minneapolis streetcar drivers walked off the job. Three hundred St. Paul drivers and other workers struck the following morning. Most of the strikers were members of the Street Railways Employees' Protective Association.

Lowry indicated that the strikers could come back to work at the reduced wage if they agreed not to participate in union activity within the company. This stipulation made the strikers more determined. They hoped that public pressure would force Lowry to restore their lost wages.

Labor leaders advised against violence, but the few streetcars that ventured out the next morning came under attack. An estimated ten thousand people gathered along the Washington Avenue line. They placed obstructions on the tracks and threw stones at the drivers. Police arrested five men, including two strikers.

The violence prompted Minneapolis Mayor Edward C. Babb to place fifty special police on cars and at the storage barns to keep the peace.

The following evening, a crowd of ten thousand gathered in Bridge Square in Minneapolis to hear labor leaders J. P. McGaughey, Tom H. Lucas, and labor journalist Eva McDonald. They favored arbitration, but because Lowry refused to cooperate, they chose a course of action calculated to end the strike quickly and favorably.

Lowry's franchise in each city depended upon all his streetcars operating on a regular schedule. The strikers reasoned that without drivers the cars couldn't operate, which would force a forfeit of each franchise. They presented a petition with twenty thousand signatures to the Minneapolis City Council citing this operation requirement. Reluctant to act, the council submitted the strikers' petition to Governor Merriam, who viewed the strike as a local government matter and declined involvement.

Another violent protest on April 17 prompted the council to mandate that all streetcar lines must be up and running by noon on April 22 or Lowry would lose his franchise. The strikers felt assured of victory.

The union's cause suffered a blow on April 20 when thirty-eight armed "cowboys" arrived from Kansas as replacement drivers. The company offered the intimidating new drivers two dollars per week and protection. Public response was one of indignation and apprehension, which led to increased support for the strikers—and increased violence.

As many as ten thousand people gathered by the tracks the next morning to greet the streetcars with a show of rocks, bricks, and bottles of acid. The mob tore up tracks and piled debris upon others. They overturned two cars, and destroyed the Riverside turntable. The protesters pulled one driver from his car and beat him. Police reinforcements arrived and made thirty-three arrests. Later that evening, union sympathizers tore up a section of the Riverside tracks and police took two more men into custody. The company ordered all cars back to the barns until morning.

The strikers recognized that the violence harmed their cause and passed a resolution condemning it. They blamed the rioting on the presence of the "cowboys" and on the actions of angry citizens.

By April 23, the strike had taken its toll on both cities and streetcar workers. Judge Isaac Atwater estimated the cost to the city of Minneapolis at five thousand dollars per day, plus losses to local businesses. The city also faced reparation costs of two thousand to three thousand due to Lowry for streetcar property damages.

Strikers in both cities were back at work by April 25, and most streetcar lines resumed operation by the end of the month.

  • Cite
  • Share
  • Correct
  • Print
© Minnesota Historical Society
  • Bibliography
  • Related Resources

"62 Cars Running." Minneapolis Journal, April 25, 1889.

"And Now Pistols!" Minneapolis Journal, April 17, 1889.

"Bells Jingle Not." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 14, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-14/ed-1/seq-2

"Cars On The Move." Minneapolis Tribune, April 18, 1889.

"A Day of Quiet." Minneapolis Tribune, April 14, 1889.

"Do Not Give It Up Yet." St. Paul Pioneer Press, April 24, 1889.

"The End Seems Near." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 23, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-23/ed-1/seq-3

Faue, Elizabeth. Writing the Wrongs: Eva Valesh and the Rise of Labor Journalism. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 2002.

"Fifty Cars Running." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 26, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-26/ed-1/seq-2

"From Mayor Babb." Minneapolis Tribune, April 15, 1889.

Gay, Eva. A tale of the Twin Cities: Lights and Shadows of the Street Car Strike in Minneapolis and St. Paul, Minnesota, Beginning April 11, 1889. Minneapolis: Thos. A. Clark & Co., 1889.

"Got the Start of Them." St. Paul Pioneer Press, April 20, 1889.

"It Seems To Be Over." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 24, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-24/ed-1/seq-3

"The Men Go Out." Minneapolis Tribune, April 12, 1889.

Millikan, William. A Union Against Unions: The Minneapolis Citizens Alliance and Fight Against Organized Labor, 1903–1947. St. Paul: Minnesota Historical Society Press, 2001.

"Moving Cautiously." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 20, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-20/ed-1/seq-3

"Mr. Lowry is Firm." Minneapolis Journal, April 13, 1889.

"Names The Limit." Minneapolis Tribune, April 20, 1889.

"Not Till Monday." Minneapolis Journal, April 13, 1889.

"Not Yet Peaceful." Minneapolis Tribune, April 23, 1889.

"Prepare To Hoof It." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 12, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-12/ed-1/seq-1

"A Riot on Sunday." St. Paul Pioneer Press, April 22, 1889.

"A Sign of Weakening."St. Paul Pioneer Press, April 23, 1889.

"Taken By Surprise." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 12, 1889.

"The True Inwardness." St. Paul Pioneer Press, April 20, 1889.

"They All Walk." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 12, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-12/ed-1/seq-1

"Wages To Be Cut." Minneapolis Tribune, April 11, 1889.

"Walk Still On." Minneapolis Tribune, April 16, 1889.

"Walking Is Good." St. Paul Daily Globe, April 13, 1889.
http://chroniclingamerica.loc.gov/lccn/sn90059522/1889-04-13/ed-1/seq-1

"Was Almost A Mob." Minneapolis Tribune, April 13, 1889.

"Women Boycott It!" Minneapolis Journal, April 19, 1889.

"Worse and Worse." Minneapolis Tribune, April 22, 1889.

Related Images

Black and white scan of "The best way to settle it." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The best way to settle it." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.
Black and white photograph of a horsecar in Minneapolis on Plymouth and Bloomington Avenue line, c.1888.
Black and white photograph of a horsecar in Minneapolis on Plymouth and Bloomington Avenue line, c.1888.
Black and white photograph of a horse-drawn streetcar in Minneapolis; sign reads Sixth Street, Monroe Street and Eighth Avenue, c.1885. This photograph shows a second team of horses ready to relieve the team on the horsecar.
Black and white photograph of a horse-drawn streetcar in Minneapolis; sign reads Sixth Street, Monroe Street and Eighth Avenue, c.1885. This photograph shows a second team of horses ready to relieve the team on the horsecar.
Black and white scan of "This style fifty cents." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.
Black and white scan of "This style fifty cents." Minneapolis Journal, April 12, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Nothing to arbitrate."  Minneapolis Journal, April 13, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Nothing to arbitrate."  Minneapolis Journal, April 13, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The real sufferer."  Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The real sufferer."  Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Mr. Lowry, having no cash to put in it, uses the office safe for a coal bin." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Mr. Lowry, having no cash to put in it, uses the office safe for a coal bin." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan "Closed on account of the strike." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan "Closed on account of the strike." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Some employers' idea of a labor agitator." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Some employers' idea of a labor agitator." Minneapolis Journal, April 15, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Mr. Lowry's 'Pigs in Clover.'" Minneapolis Journal, April 16, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Mr. Lowry's 'Pigs in Clover.'" Minneapolis Journal, April 16, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Seen on First Avenue South." Minneapolis Journal, April 16, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Seen on First Avenue South." Minneapolis Journal, April 16, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Arresting the two young dynamiters who put paper caps on the rails. Minneapolis Journal, April 18, 1889.
Black and white scan of "Arresting the two young dynamiters who put paper caps on the rails. Minneapolis Journal, April 18, 1889.
Black and white scan of "To be seen on the patrol box at Nicollet Av. and Sixth St." Minneapolis Journal, April 19, 1889.
Black and white scan of "To be seen on the patrol box at Nicollet Av. and Sixth St." Minneapolis Journal, April 19, 1889.
Black and white scan of "On the motor – the new conductor announcing the streets." Minneapolis Journal, April 20, 1889.
Black and white scan of "On the motor – the new conductor announcing the streets." Minneapolis Journal, April 20, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The result of ten days' walking." Minneapolis Journal, April 20, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The result of ten days' walking." Minneapolis Journal, April 20, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The situation changed." Minneapolis Journal, April 22, 1889.
Black and white scan of "The situation changed." Minneapolis Journal, April 22, 1889.

Turning Point

On April 20, 1889, the arrival of thirty-eight substitute streetcar drivers from Kansas helps break the strike on Lowry's street railway franchise.

Chronology

April 10, 1889

Thomas Lowry announces a 15 percent pay cut for all Minneapolis street railway company employees.

April 11, 1889

Six hundred Minneapolis streetcar drivers walk off the job.

April 11, 1889

Lowry posts the notice of wage reductions for all St. Paul street railway company employees.

April 12, 1889

Three hundred St. Paul streetcar drivers join the strike.

April 13, 1889

The first incident of violence occurs when an angry mob pelts drivers with stones and blocks streetcar tracks after a large labor rally in Bridge Square.

April 17, 1889

Following another violent protest, the Minneapolis City Council mandates that all streetcar lines must be back in operation by April 22, or Lowry will lose his franchise.

April 19, 1889

Thirty-eight armed "cowboys" arrive from Kansas to drive streetcars during the strike, which foils the strikers' plan to halt all streetcar operations.

April 21, 1889

A large crowd of angry citizens and strikers attacks cars and tears up tracks.

April 22, 1889

Five streetcar lines are back in operation with little interference.

April 24, 1889

The strike ends in Minneapolis as some employees return to work and sixty-two cars return to service.

April 25, 1889

The strike ends in St. Paul and fifty streetcars return to service.